Bank on Banking

This is an interesting question I received from a reader a while back, and I felt it was worth its own posting. I know it is not my longest article, but definitely worth a read and worth some consideration as well all continue to evaluate our career paths and take our next steps.

On a side note, it’s definitely been a busy several weeks for a variety of reasons ultimately leaving me without much free time to compose articles or properly field questions. Although my schedule will definitely be fairly packed over the next several weeks, it has lightened a bit and I will definitely be returning to a more consistent level of posting and answering questions. And I know I’ve been saying it for a while now, but my new product is absolutely coming very soon and will make the technical side of your upcoming interviews much easier! That said – let’s jump right in!

Although the immediate move from IB to PE/HF/buyside in general results in better compensation initially, is it worth it in the long run? In other words, should one transition to buyside, or stay the course with banking, if possible, and attempt to move into an MD role at a BB, for example? Also, does moving to an MD role at a BB require an MBA degree? In my mind, this seems to be a much safer path than moving to a Hedge Fund, for example, which can go bust, and since differences at the MD level for pay between BB Investment Banks and Buy Side PE firms are little, is the move really worth it?

Ok – that was definitely a mouth/eye/ear full, but I’m going to break out some of the key points and address them accordingly:

1. The move from analyst to MD does NOT require an MBA by any means. However, the path is definitely a one to take and one that often involves layoffs, bank changes, being passed up for opportunities, and so forth. Moving from analyst to associate is one thing; moving from analyst to some sort of VP is another thing, but to go from analyst up to MD is absolutely no small task given the rate of turnover, movement between banks, cyclicality of the business, need for additional resources (meaning MDs aren’t just given – they are doled out based on need of a team or group) and so forth. Don’t get me wrong, it can certainly happen (as needed) and the moves from analyst to VP and D definitely happen, but it often comes with a bumpy and lengthy road. Remember, just because an organization is large or established, it does not automatically follow that your career will be secure and that promotions are natural and easy steps. If there is a big turn in the market, as we’ve all just seen and are continuing to witness these past few years, hedge funds, PE shops, small banks, BB banks and the like were all taking butcher’s knives to their staffs.

2. Even though the progression can happen, it isn’t one of those things where everyone wants to do it and just doesn’t get picked. Most people use IB as not necessarily a stepping stone, but definitely a means of reaching an end, not an end in itself. Post analyst and associate roles are in PE, HF, VC, buyside, boutiques, F500 and so forth and are often far more lucrative for much bigger reasons than dollars. Many people just don’t want to deal with the hours, the stress, the credit committees and internal politics (jumping through hoops to get deals approved and so forth, especially in a still jittery market like this) the NEED for new business, etc – since remember, IB is a sales position at the end of the day, and working for a BB bank means you need to constantly be selling and showing the bank that you are worth the bonus and worth a cube or office on the floor. Even senior bankers work long hours and although they aren’t at their desks for 12, 15+ hours, they are often on the road visiting clients, pitching, negotiating terms and so forth several days per week.

3. At the end of the day, it is really a personal call. If you like the sell-side (IB-side) of the business and many people do, then you will want to stick it out, or possibly pursue an MBA and then get back in to move to a stronger/more prestigious bank, new group, fresh start, etc. If, however, you aren’t passionate or as passionate about IB necessarily and just want to put in the time to gain the contacts and the experience and skill set/transaction knowledge and move on, then becoming a senior banker will definitely not be for you. In that case, you are much better off moving to buyside, in some form, and enjoy.